Attorneys’ Fees and the American Arbitration Association Rule
September 09, 2024 —
Bill Wilson - Construction Law ZoneA common question from clients, when a dispute arises on a construction project, is whether they can recover their attorney’s fees from the other side if they pursue a case and win. More often than not, such fees are not recoverable. As a general rule (commonly known as the “American Rule”), each party to a dispute must bear their own attorney’s fees unless there is some statutory provision or contractual agreement between the parties allowing otherwise. Since most construction disputes involve claims for breach of contract and/or negligence, no realistic statutory provision often allows for attorney’s fees. Many construction contracts do not typically provide a prevailing party the right to collect attorney’s fees from the other side. However, even if the American Rule applies, there may be another path to recovering attorney’s fees if the parties agree to arbitrate their dispute under the American Arbitration Association (AAA) rules.
Reprinted courtesy of
Bill Wilson, Robinson & Cole LLP
Mr. Wilson may be contacted at wwilson@rc.com
Read the full story...
There Are Consequences to Executed Documents Such as the Accord and Satisfaction Defense
October 01, 2024 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesA federal government contractor in Jackson Construction Co., Inc. v. U.S., 62 Fed.Cl. 84 (Fed.Cl. 2024) sought delay damages against the government. It lost. The reason for the loss is a crucial reminder that documents parties sign ALWAYS matter. ALWAYS!!
In Jackson Construction Co., the contractor’s delay claim was premised on relocating a waterline. The contractor, however, received additional money for relocating the waterline, but no additional time, and this was memorialized in a modification to the contract (i.e., a change order). In executing the modification for the additional work, the contractor did NOT reserve rights for time or money. Indeed, the modification reflected that the monetary adjustment constitutes full compensation for the additional work including delay, namely:
The contract period of performance remains the same. It is further understood and agreed that this adjustment constitutes compensation in full on behalf of the contractor and his subcontractors and suppliers for all costs and markup directly or indirectly, including extended overhead, attributable to the change order, for all delays related thereto, and for performance of the change within the time frame stated.
Jackson Construction Co., supra, at 90.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin Norris, P.A.Mr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
Untangling Unique Legal Issues in Modern Modular Construction
September 09, 2024 —
Chad Theriot & Brad Sands - Construction ExecutiveModular construction has grown significantly over the last few years and shows no signs of slowing down. This construction method is a departure from traditional approaches where all construction activity occurs onsite. Modular construction involves building standardized project components—usually in an offsite, controlled environment—which are then transported and assembled at the project site. Offsite construction generally allows for better quality control and economic efficiency, as it can utilize an assembly-line process. Modular fabrication can also centralize skilled labor in regions with lower labor costs.
Establishing each party's expectations upfront is always important, but even more so in modular construction since much of the construction activity is performed away from the ultimate project site. This requires extensive coordination among designers, fabricators, installers and owners to ensure construction, testing and quality progresses accordingly. Every field change and design clash could have an exponential impact on the modular fabrication efficiencies given the assembly-line approach and remote nature of modular work.
Reprinted courtesy of
Chad Theriot & Brad Sands, Construction Executive, a publication of Associated Builders and Contractors. All rights reserved.
Read the full story...
Damage Control: Major Rebuilds After Major Weather Events
October 21, 2024 —
David McMillin - Construction ExecutiveMore than two feet of rain drenching Fort Lauderdale in a day, baseball-sized hail chunks falling on Minneapolis and the deadliest wildfire in more than a century destroying more than 2,100 acres of Maui—2023 was a stark reminder that Mother Nature is a force to be reckoned with. In total, $28 billion dollars’ worth of extreme weather and climate-related disasters ripped across the U.S. last year—a new record, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. And there’s no relief in sight: 2024 is already the second-busiest tornado season on the books, and wildfires were burning in Oregon, California, Montana and Texas as this issue went to print.
Part of dealing with disasters is preparing for their impact to infrastructure, and Roland Orgeron Jr.—who co-founded New Orleans-based Legacy Industries with business partner Blake Couch in 2016—has been helping clients do just that. “We do a lot of consulting to identify vulnerabilities, and we offer action plans for companies based on potential storm scenarios,” Orgeron Jr. says.
Some of those clients include large oil and gas companies with operations along the Mississippi River that cannot afford to be shut down for any extended period. “Before Hurricane Ida hit, we pre-positioned equipment inside some facilities, and we had guys responding the day after the storm to clear the area and assess the damage,” Orgeron Jr. says. During the immediate response to Hurricane Ida in 2021, the company’s work involved more than keeping the business locations up and running; they needed to help a business’ employees find a place to live. “We have a home stabilization contract with one oil and gas company designed to make sure their employees can get back to work as comfortably and quickly as possible,” Orgeron Jr. says.
Reprinted courtesy of
David McMillin, Construction Executive, a publication of Associated Builders and Contractors. All rights reserved.
Read the full story...
With Trump's Tariff Talk, Time to Negotiate for Escalation Clauses in Construction Contracts
December 17, 2024 —
Richard Korman - Engineering News-RecordRemember 2019? That’s when contractors faced sudden material price surges from tariffs during then-President Donald Trump’s first term in office. How about 2021? That's when contractors saw new price surges and long delivery delays because of Covid-19.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Richard Korman, ENRMr. Korman may be contacted at
kormanr@enr.com
Fall 2024 Legislative Update:
October 28, 2024 —
Joshua Lane - Ahlers Cressman & Sleight PLLCReview of (a) RCW 60.30.010-020, (b) RCW 49.17.530, (c) RCW 19.95.020, (d) RCW 39.116.005, et seq., (e) RCW 36.70B.080, and (f) RCW 39.12.010 and .13
While much of the focus on the recent legislative updates has been on RCW 39.04.360, a number of other legislative changes may also have significant impacts on Washington’s construction industry. Six of these changes are summarized below.
A. RCW 60.30.010 and .020 (SSB 6108) – Concerning Retainage on Private Construction, Effective June 6, 2024
Last year, ESSB 5528 imposed restrictions and obligations related to retainage and timing of final payment on private (non-public works) projects. It capped retainage at 5%, required prompt payment on final payments, and required owners to accept a retainage bond on private construction projects, excluding single-family residential construction less than 12 units.
This year, SSB 6108 adds suppliers to the statutes (RCW 60.30.010 and 0.020) pertaining to retainage on private construction projects.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Joshua Lane, Ahlers Cressman & Sleight PLLCMr. Lane may be contacted at
joshua.lane@acslawyers.com
ASCE Statement on Hurricane Milton and Environmental Threats
October 15, 2024 —
Feniosky Peña-Mora, P.E., President - American Society of Civil EngineersWASHINGTON, DC. – On the heels of the tragic damage caused by Hurricane Helene throughout the Southeast, Floridians were struck by another major hurricane, Milton, less than two weeks later. Our hearts go out to those impacted again by this storm through property damage, lack of water access, power outages, or worse, loss of life, all before getting a chance to recover from Helene. Civil engineers are dedicated to protecting the public with projects that can lessen the impacts of these storms, and we are eager to help communities rebuild as quickly as possible following events like Milton and Helene.
Although we do not yet know the full scope of destruction caused by Hurricane Milton, severe weather, including compound flooding events, are increasing regularly and pose a great risk to our safety and economic vitality. While so many eyes are fixated on hurricanes impacting the Southeast, wildfires are burning across several western states, including the Elk Fire in Wyoming, the largest wildfire the Bighorn National Forest has experienced in more than a century, now spanning over 75,000 acres as the region is experiencing unusually hot and dry weather and strong winds that are helping this fire to spread rapidly. The climate impacts we are accustomed to – wildfires in the West and hurricanes in the Southeast – are getting stronger, and now environmental challenges are occurring in areas
Construction Up in Northern OhioHaight Welcomes Elizabeth LawleyPollution Exclusion Does Not Apply To Concrete Settling DustInsurers Need only Prove that Other Coverage Exists for Construction Defect ClaimsShea Homes CEO Receives Hearthstone Builder Humanitarian AwardEditorial: Qatar Is Champion of Safety Hypocrisy in Migrant Worker Deaths Miller Law Firm Helped HOA Recover for Construction Defects without Filing a LawsuitGeneral Contractors Must Plan to Limit Liability for Subcontractor InjuryEngineering Report Finds More Investigation Needed of Balconies at New Jersey CondoContractual Warranty Agreements May Preclude Future Tort RecoveryInspectors Hurry to Make Sure Welds Are Right before Bay Bridge OpeningCase Dispositive Motion for Summary Judgment Granted for BWB&O’s Client in Wrongful Death Case!When Your “Private” Project Suddenly Turns into a “Public” Project. Hint: It Doesn’t Necessary Turn on Public Financing or Construction Statutes of Limitations May be the Colorado Contractors’ FriendLatest Updates On The Coronavirus PandemicKaylin Jolivette Named LADC's Construction and Commercial Practice ChairReal Estate & Construction News Roundup (10/16/24) – Chevron Ruling’s Impact on Construction Industry, New Kind of Public Housing and Policy Recommendations from Sustainable Building GroupsThe Quiet War Between California’s Charter Cities and the State’s Prevailing Wage LawPreventing Acts of God: Construction Accidents Caused by Outside FactorsNorth Dakota Court Determines Inadvertent Faulty Workmanship is an "Occurrence"Palm Beach Billionaires’ Fix for Sinking Megamansions: Build BiggerFive "Boilerplate" Terms to Negotiate in Your Next SubcontractCongratulations to Arezoo Jamshidi & Michael Parme Selected to the 2022 San Diego Super Lawyers Rising Stars ListFive New Laws to Know Before They Take Effect On Jan. 1, 2022There’s an Unusual Thing Happening in the Housing MarketBalancing Risk and Reward: The Complexities of Stadium Construction ProjectsConstruction-Industry Clients Need Well-Reasoned and Clear Policies on Recording Zoom and Teams MeetingsFederal Contractors – Double Check the Terms of Your Contract Before Performing Ordered ChangesReal Estate & Construction News Roundup (09/12/23) – Airbnb’s Future in New York City, MGM Resorts Suffer Cybersecurity Incident, and Insurance Costs Hitting Commercial Real EstateDraft Federal Legislation Reinforces Advice to Promptly Notify Insurers of COVID-19 LossesChallenging and Defending a California Public Works Stop Payment Notice: Affidavit vs. Counter-Affidavit Process Did You Get a Notice of Mechanic’s Lien after Project Completion? Don’t Panic!Slow Down?ASCE and Accelerator for America Release Map to Showcase Projects from Bipartisan Infrastructure LawCalifornia Supreme Court Declines to Create Exception to Privette Doctrine for “Known Hazards”Structure of Champlain Towers North Appears HealthyMontana Significantly Revises Its Product Liability LawsSteel Component Plant Linked to West Virginia Governor Signs $1M Pollution PactInsurer's Bad Faith is Actionable Tort for Purposes of Choice of Law AnalysisReal Estate & Construction News Round-Up (01/11/23) – Construction Tech, Housing Market Confidence, and DecarbonizationCongratulations to BWB&O for Ranking #4 in Orange County Business Journal’s 2023 Book of Lists for Law Firms!Remodels Replace Construction in ReddingIntel's $20B Ohio 'Mega-Site' is Latest Development in Chip Makers' Rush to Boost US ProductionAs Fracture Questions Remain, Team Raced to Save Mississippi River BridgeDaily Reports – The Swiss Army Knife of Project DocumentationNinth Circuit: Speculative Injuries Do Not Confer Article III StandingDespite Misapplying California Law, Federal Court Acknowledges Virus May Cause Physical Alteration to PropertyBP Is Not an Additional Insured Under Transocean's PolicyChicago Developer and Trade Group Sue City Over Affordable Housing RequirementsClient Alert: Absence of a Court Reporter at a Civil Motion Hearing May Preclude Appellate ReviewMissouri Protects Subrogation RightsFifth Circuit: Primary Insurer Relieved of Duty to Defend Without Release of Liability of InsuredFailure to Timely File Suit in Federal Court for Flood Loss is FatalCentury Communities Acquires Dunhill Homes Las Vegas OperationsShutdowns? What A Covid-19-Safe Construction Site Looks LikeTennessee Looks to Define Improvements to Real PropertyQuick Note: Not In Contract With The Owner? Serve A Notice To Owner.Massachusetts Pulls Phased Trigger On Its Statute of ReposeConstruction Case Alert: Appellate Court Confirms Engineer’s Duty to Defend Developer Arises Upon Tender of Indemnity ClaimWashington High Court Holds Insurers Bound by Representations in Agent’s Certificates of InsuranceTexas Supreme Court Authorizes Exception to the "Eight-Corners" Rule#10 CDJ Topic: Carithers v. Mid-Continent Casualty CompanyCollapse of Underground Storage Cave Not CoveredHilti Partners with Canvas, a Construction Robotics CompanyContractor Pleads Guilty to Disadvantaged-Business FraudCourt Finds Matching of Damaged Materials is Required by PolicyColorado Senate Committee Approves Construction Defect BillReplevin Actions: What You Should KnowBoilerplate Contract Language on Permits could cause Problems for ContractorsVaccine Mandate Confusion Continues – CMS Vaccine Mandate Restored in Some (But Not All) US StatesSenate Committee Approves Military Construction FundsWhat is Toxic Mold Litigation? 
