Another Reminder that Your Construction Contract is Only as Good as Those Signing It
December 17, 2024 —
Christopher G. Hill - Construction Law MusingsHere at Construction Law Musings, we beat the constant drum that “
the contract is king” and “draft a
good and well-worded construction contract” consistently. As a
Virginia construction attorney, I stand by these statements and fully endorse a well-written construction contract. Such a contract will set expectations and
provide the rules for your deal (particularly in the commercial context). Without this solid foundation (yes, I see the potential construction pun), when
there are issues on the job site, there will be no baseline for how to resolve those issues.
That said, I am also reminded on an almost daily basis that humans interact with these contracts. People negotiate the contracts and are the main forces that drive the success (or failure) of the construction project. Money is involved (often a lot of it) and there can at times be temptations to try and squeeze one last dollar out of the job despite what the contract says. Even the strongest contract cannot act as real-time protection against one party that refuses to comply with the contract and its performance or payment terms.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
The Law Office of Christopher G. HillMr. Hill may be contacted at
chrisghill@constructionlawva.com
Big Data Meets Big Green: Data Centers and Carbon Removal Compete for Zero-Emission Energy
October 15, 2024 —
Robert A. James, Sidney L. Fowler & Ashleigh Myers - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogArtificial intelligence, data centers, carbon removal and zero-emission power may sound like a winning line (plus the Free Space) on a 2024 Buzzword Bingo card. But the concepts have come into dramatic real-world tension as private and public actors seek to accommodate the digital and environmental imperatives for green energy.
After years of fairly stable demand, punctuated by declines during the pandemic and economic slumps, electricity demand is projected to double by 2050. A principal cause is the rapid expansion in the power needed to energize and cool servers amid explosive growth in the number and size of data centers, crypto miners, and other point sources of computation. Data centers were 3% of U.S. demand and are projected to be up to 9% or more by 2030; AI will drive a 160% surge in data center demand by 2030. A commentator notes, “We haven’t seen [growth like] this in a generation.”
Reprinted courtesy of
Robert A. James, Pillsbury,
Sidney L. Fowler, Pillsbury and
Ashleigh Myers, Pillsbury
Mr. James may be contacted at rob.james@pillsburylaw.com
Mr. Fowler may be contacted at sidney.fowler@pillsburylaw.com
Ms. Myers may be contacted at ashleigh.myers@pillsburylaw.com
Read the full story...
“Since You Asked. . .”
October 15, 2024 —
Daniel Lund III - Lexology… you must now pay.
So said a California appellate court, affirming the trial court’s decision against a subcontractor suing for unpaid subcontract sums. Instead of being awarded those unpaid amounts, the subcontractor lost the case and was tagged with a $1.55 million attorney’s fees award and $270,000 costs award in favor of the defendants.
What went wrong?
California law requires a licensed contractor to maintain at all times proper workers’ compensation insurance coverage. The failure to maintain the coverage and have the certificate of coverage on file with the California Contractors State License Board results in “automatic and immediate suspension” of the contractor license. Retroactive reinstatement of the license may occur only if the contractor provides proof of the insurance within 90 days of the effective date of the insurance certificate – unless the contractor can show that failure to have the certificate on file was “due to circumstances beyond the control of the licensee.”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Daniel Lund III, PhelpsMr. Lund may be contacted at
daniel.lund@phelps.com
Blog Completes Seventeenth Year
January 07, 2025 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiInsurance Law Hawaii reaches the end of its seventeenth year this month. We began posting long ago, in December 2007.
We seek to keep readers apprised of developments in insurance-related cases from Hawaii and across the country. Coverage issues surrounding the Maui fires have been top of mind this year. We will continue posting on important coverage developments in the next year.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
In Appellate Division First, New York Appellate Team Successfully Invokes “Party Finality” Doctrine to Obtain Dismissal of Appeal for Commercial Guarantors
December 23, 2024 —
Dean Pillarella - Lewis BrisboisNew York, N.Y. (November 20, 2024) - In Roc-Le Triomphe Associates, LLC v. DeSouza, 2024 NY Slip Op 05654 (1st Dep’t 2024), Associate Dean Pillarella, a member of the Appellate Practice, successfully invoked the party finality doctrine to obtain the dismissal of an appeal for the firm’s commercial guarantor clients.
The action concerned rent allegedly due and owing under a commercial lease by the lease’s tenant and guarantors. Pursuant to a 2022 order, the guarantors were awarded summary judgment and dismissal of all claims against them, with the landlord’s claims against the tenant left intact. After the decision and order was served with notice of entry by the prevailing party, the landlord did not file a notice of appeal from the order but, instead, filed a notice of appeal from a later judgment months after the time to appeal the order had expired.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Dean Pillarella, Lewis BrisboisMr. Pillarella may be contacted at
Dean.Pillarella@lewisbrisbois.com
Dozens Missing in LA as High Winds Threaten to Spark More Fires
January 14, 2025 —
Laura Curtis & Brian K Sullivan - BloombergHot, dry winds are pummeling Los Angeles and surrounding areas of Southern California, raising wildfire risks through at least Wednesday as the region reels from blazes that have killed at least 24 people and burned neighborhoods to the ground.
Tropical-storm-strength winds were raking the mountains around LA on Tuesday, with gusts reaching 60 miles (97 kilometers) per hour. About 2 million people face extreme fire conditions across a swath of land that includes Oxnard, Thousand Oaks and Simi Valley, according to the US Storm Prediction Center. Red-flag fire warnings extend south to San Diego.
Reprinted courtesy of
Laura Curtis, Bloomberg and
Brian K Sullivan, Bloomberg Read the full story...
The Benefits of Trash Talking: A Cautionary Tale of Demolition Gone Wrong
September 02, 2024 —
Joshua Levy, Anne O'Meara & Kimberly Gutierrez - Construction ExecutiveThat sinking feeling has crossed everyone’s mind at some point: "Did I accidentally throw out...?” It can happen to anyone, from valuable jewelry to uncashed checks or even (in the case of one contractor) to fire-pump control cabinets.
Demolishing the wrong equipment is a concern construction and demolition contractors should review before beginning any project. Recently, one general contractor and its demolition subcontractor would have benefitted from a more detailed “trash” talking session, which could have helped them avoid a dumpster-fire of a legal dispute.
In this case, the general contractor was contracted to renovate a hangar for a military base. The company subcontracted the demolition work to a local, family-owned contractor to demolish aspects of the hangar’s fire-suppression room. The two companies met many times, from planning to daily field walk-downs. They discussed that any equipment that was tagged with bright orange tags would remain in the fire-suppression room. The contractor also reviewed the demolition plans with the demolition company, detailing what should and should not be removed.
Reprinted courtesy of
Joshua Levy, Anne O'Meara & Kimberly Gutierrez, Construction Executive, a publication of Associated Builders and Contractors. All rights reserved.
Read the full story...
“A No-Lose Proposition?”
October 07, 2024 —
Daniel Lund III - LexologyA Miller Act payment bond surety and its principal general contractor both sued in federal court in New Orleans by a project subcontractor sought to compel arbitration the claims against both contractor and surety based on an indisputably enforceable arbitration clause in the subcontract. This was urged to avoid separate actions against the contractor (arbitration) and its surety (litigation), even though the surety was not a party to the subcontract and, therefore, not a party to the arbitration clause.
In the face of the lack of an express agreement to arbitrate, the contractor and contractor argued that “no federal statute or policy prohibits all of Plaintiff’s claims from proceeding to arbitration….” Additionally, those parties urged that the surety should be allowed to affirmatively compel arbitration because the surety “would otherwise have the ability to assert the right to compel arbitration as a defense….”
The New Orleans federal district court was unpersuaded:
“[D]istrict courts within this circuit have recognized that ‘Miller Act claims by a subcontractor for unpaid labor and materials are separate and distinct from those for general breach of contract… [and] arbitration and Miller Act suits, are not, per se, inconsistent with one another.’…[A]bsent express contractual intent to subject Miller Act claims to arbitration, the court [will] not force the parties to arbitrate claims against nonparties to the contract at issue…. [C]laims against a surety, which was a non-signatory to the contract, would not be subject to arbitration without any contractual basis to do so.”
Overtime! – When the Statute of Limitations Isn’t Game Over For Your ClaimOhio Condo Owners Sue Builder, Alleging Construction DefectsThe Argument for Solar Power2018 Super Bowl US. Bank Stadium in Minneapolis Contractors and Owners Will Have an Easier Time Identifying Regulated Wetlands Following Recent U.S. Supreme Court OpinionU.S. Supreme Court Limits the Powers of the Nation’s Bankruptcy CourtsCouple Claims Contractor’s Work Is Defective and Incomplete"Repair Work" Endorsements and Punch List WorkPerez Broke Records … But Should He Have Settled Earlier?Georgia Amends Anti-Indemnity StatuteWhat to Look for in Subcontractor Warranty EndorsementsUnqualified Threat to Picket a Neutral is Unfair Labor PracticeThe Hidden Price of Outdated Damage Prevention Laws: Part IWest Coast
Metrostudy Shows New Subdivisions in Midwest
Federal Court Denies Summary Judgment in Leaky Condo Conversion
Missouri Protects Subrogation Rights
Search in Florida Collapse to Take Weeks; Deaths Reach 90
Can Your Small Business Afford to Risk the Imminent Threat of a Cyber Incident?
Lewis Brisbois Ranks 11th in Law360’s Glass Ceiling Report on Gender Parity in Law Firms
Colorado Senate Bill 13-052 Dies in Committee
Prompt Payment More Likely on Residential Construction Jobs Than Commercial or Public Jobs
Important Information Regarding Colorado Mechanic’s Lien Rights.
Candis Jones Named to Atlanta Magazine’s 2024 “Atlanta 500” List
Another Law Will Increase Construction Costs in New York
NJ Transit’s Superstorm Sandy Coverage Victory Highlights Complexities of Underwriting Property Insurance Towers
Subcontractors Found Liable to Reimburse Insurer Defense Costs in Equitable Subrogation Action
Decades of WCC Seminar at the Disneyland Resort
Traub Lieberman Chair Emeritus Awarded the 2022 Vince Donohue Award by the International Association of Claim Professionals
New Illinois Supreme Court Trigger Rule for CGL Personal Injury “Offenses” Could Have Costly Consequences for Policyholders
From Both Sides Now: Looking at Contracts Through a Post-Pandemic Lens
Contractors: Revisit your Force Majeure Provisions to Account for Hurricanes
Blog Completes Fifteenth Year
New-Home Sales in U.S. Unexpectedly Fall to Four-Month Low
#4 CDJ Topic: Vita Planning and Landscape Architecture, Inc. v. HKS Architects, Inc.
California Case Is a Reminder That Not All Insurance Policies Are Alike Regarding COVID-19 Losses
School’s Lawsuit over Defective Field Construction Delayed
“Based On”… What Exactly? NJ Appellate Division Examines Phrase and Estops Insurer From Disclaiming Coverage for 20-Month Delay
Nomos LLP Partner Garret Murai Recognized by Super Lawyers
Falls Requiring Time Off from Work are Increasing
Cogently Written Opinion Finds Coverage for Loss Caused By Defective Concrete
The 2017 ASCDC and CDCMA Construction Defect Seminar and Holiday Reception
‘Like a War Zone’: Malibu Fire Ravages Multimillion-Dollar Homes
It’s a Bird, It’s a Plane . . . No, It’s a Drone. Long Awaited FAA Drone Regulations Finally Take Flight
A Court-Side Seat: A FACA Fight, a Carbon Pledge and Some Venue on the SCOTUS Menu
Nevada Senate Minority Leader Confident about Construction Defect Bill
Five Years of Great Legal Blogging at Insurance Law Hawaii
BOO! Running From Chainsaw Wielding Actor then Falling is an Inherent Risk of a Haunted Attraction
Newmeyer Dillion Attorneys Named to 2022 Super Lawyers and Rising Stars Lists
Residential Building Sector: Peaking or Soaring?
Look Out! Texas Building Shedding Marble Panels
New York Developer gets Reprieve in Leasehold Battle
Best Practices in Construction– What are Yours?
Investigators Explain Focus on Pre-Collapse Cracking in Florida Bridge
Examination of the Product Does Not Stop a Pennsylvania Court From Applying the Malfunction Theory
Harmon Towers Demolition Still Uncertain
Let it Shine: California Mandates Rooftop Solar for New Residential Construction
THE CALIFORNIA SUPREME COURT HAS RULED THAT THE RIGHT TO REPAIR ACT (SB800) IS THE EXCLUSIVE REMEDY FOR CONSTRUCTION DEFECT CLAIMS NOT INVOLVING PERSONAL INJURIES WHETHER OR NOT THE UNDERLYING DEFECTS GAVE RISE TO ANY PROPERTY DAMAGE in McMillin Albany LL
Dump Site Provider Has Valid Little Miller Act Claim
BHA Expands Construction Experts Group
Exculpatory Provisions in Business Contracts
Wells Fargo, JPMorgan Vexed by Low Demand for Mortgages
National Demand Increases for Apartments, Refuting Calls for Construction Defect Immunity in Colorado
New Jersey Court Washes Away Insurer’s Waiver of Subrogation Arguments
