Contractual Fee-Shifting in Litigation: Who Pays the Price?
December 31, 2024 —
Caitlin Kicklighter - ConsensusDocsWhen disputes on a construction project escalate to litigation, general contractors may find themselves entangled in a costly and time-consuming legal battle. One important concept to understand is contractual fee-shifting under a “prevailing party” provision, which can significantly impact damages recovered in litigation. The general rule, known as the “American Rule,” requires each party to pay its own legal costs, including attorney’s fees, expert witness expenses, and other court-related costs. This differs from other legal systems where the losing party typically pays the winning party’s fees. One exception to the American Rule is contractual fee-shifting, specifically through “prevailing party” provisions, which allows for the award of attorney’s fees and costs when explicitly provided for in a contract.
This article explores this exception to the American Rule, delves into the challenges posed by prevailing party provisions, and shares tips to consider for drafting these clauses to improve clarity and minimize uncertainty in the face of litigation.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Caitlin Kicklighter, Jones Walker LLPMs. Kicklighter may be contacted at
ckicklighter@joneswalker.com
Construction Defect Claim Survives Insurer's Summary Judgment Motion Due to Lack of Evidence
December 23, 2024 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe court denied the insurer's motion for summary judgment on a construction defect claim due to lack of evidence. Statesboro Erectors, Inc. v. Owners Ins. Co., 2024 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 176555 (N.D. Ga. Sept. 30, 2024).
Griffco was the general contractor for a construction project. King Steel was hired as the "steel fabricator." King Steel subcontracted with Statesboro Erectors to complete certain construction work at the site. Statesboro agreed to the complete, proper and safe erection of the structural steel.
A steel collapse occurred at the construction site. According to King Steel, the collapse "appeared to have occurred due to lack of temporary cables or bracing for steel columns." Because of the collapse, King Steel was required to supply additional materials to replace the structural damage caused by the collapse.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
First Circuit Finds No Coverage For Subcontracted Faulty Work
December 17, 2024 —
Eric Hermanson & Austin Moody - White and Williams LLPAfter almost two years' deliberation, the First Circuit last week issued its long-awaited decision in Admiral Ins. Co. v. Tocci Bldg. Corp.[1]: affirming on other grounds, and leaving in place a district court decision that found subcontracted faulty work was not an "occurrence" and did not lead to covered “property damage” under Massachusetts law.
The decision leaves Massachusetts among a number of states where general contractors should not expect coverage from their commercial general liability (CGL) insurers for damage falling within the contractor’s scope of work.
Since the "scope of work" – where general contractors are involved – often encompasses an entire project, contractors who want coverage in Massachusetts should take care to make alternative arrangements: transferring risk to subcontractors through indemnity provisions and additional-insured endorsements, or relying on other policy forms where available.
Reprinted courtesy of
Eric Hermanson, White and Williams LLP and
Austin Moody, White and Williams LLP
Mr. Hermanson may be contacted at hermansone@whiteandwilliams.com
Mr. Moody may be contacted at moodya@whiteandwilliams.com
Read the full story...
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (12/4/24) – Highest Rate of Office Conversions, Lending Caps for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and Affordability Challenges for Homebuyers
December 23, 2024 —
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogIn our latest roundup, infrastructure-related ballot initiatives, U.S. Green Building Council’s success stories, support for sustainable building, and more!
- 2024 is expected to see the highest rate of office conversions since CBRE began tracking them in 2016. (Nish Amarnath, SmartCities Dive)
- The Federal Housing Finance Agency has established lending caps of $73 billion each for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, allowing them to purchase a total of up to $146 billion in multifamily loans in 2025. (Leslie Shaver, Multifamily Dive)
- A number of infrastructure-related initiatives with the potential to impact facilities managers were on the ballot during the 2024 U.S. presidential election. (Joe Burns, Construction Dive)
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Pillsbury's Construction & Real Estate Law Team
Courthouse Reporter Series: Nebraska Court of Appeals Vacates Arbitration Award for Misconduct
November 18, 2024 —
Brendan J. Witry - The Dispute ResolverVacating an arbitration award is often seen as an uphill battle. Indeed, the U.S. Supreme Court has stated that “courts may only vacate an arbitrator’s decision ‘only in very unusual circumstances.’” Oxford Health Plans, LLC v. Sutter, 569 U.S. 564, 568 (2013). The Federal Arbitration Act provides limited grounds to seek the vacatur of an arbitration award. In Lund-Ross Constructors v. Duke of Omaga, LLC, ___ N.W.3d ___, 33 Neb.App.73, the Nebraska Court of Appeals found that an arbitrator’s conduct warranted the partial vacatur of the award, which granted relief to a subcontractor who filed a counterclaim after the arbitration hearing had closed.
Lund-Ross contracted with Duke of Omaha to build an apartment complex in Omaha. Lund-Ross, in turn, sub-contracted with A Raymond Plumbing. Following completion of the building, Owner withheld payment from Lund-Ross, who in turn, withheld payment from Raymond. Both Lund-Ross and Raymond filed mechanics liens and initiated suits; Raymond’s suit ultimately was dismissed for want of prosecution. Lund-Ross proceeded to arbitration with Owner, naming Raymond as a respondent. Raymond did not participate in the arbitration as a claimant at the time of the hearing.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Brendan J. Witry, Laurie & Brennan LLPMr. Witry may be contacted at
bwitry@lauriebrennan.com
Construction of World's Tallest Building to Resume With New $1.9B Contract for Jeddah Tower
October 28, 2024 —
James Leggate - Engineering News-RecordConstruction of the Jeddah Tower in Jeddah, Saudi Arabia—which is planned to be the world’s tallest building—is set to resume with original contractor Saudi Binladin Group Co. after a years-long pause, owner Jeddah Economic Co.'s parent company, Kingdom Holding Co., announced Oct. 2.
Reprinted courtesy of
James Leggate, Engineering News-Record
Mr. Leggate may be contacted at leggatej@enr.com
Read the full story...
When Licensing Lapses: How One Contractor Lost a $1 Million Dispute
October 28, 2024 —
Matthew DeVries - Best Practices Construction LawAs a construction lawyer, contractor licensing is a very key aspect of my practice. This can include new contractor applications, increase or changes in monetary limits or license classifications, change in ownership or qualifying agent , and, of course, licensing violations.
The recent decision in Incident365 Florida, LLC v. Ocean Pointe V Condominium Association serves as an important reminder for general contractors and subcontractors regarding the significance of proper licensing and thorough contract review in disaster recovery and construction services.
Case Overview
In this case, Incident365 Florida, LLC entered into disaster recovery agreements with several condominium associations (“Associations”) following Hurricane Irma. The agreements involved various tasks such as water damage mitigation, dehumidification, and the removal of unsalvageable materials. However, Incident365 lacked the appropriate contractor’s license when performing the work, which became a focal point in the dispute when the Associations refused to pay the remaining balance of $1 million, citing the absence of the required licensure.
New Jersey Strengthens the Structural Integrity of Its Residential BuildsConstruction Contract Clauses That May or May Not Have Your Vote – Part 3Subcontractor Not Liable for Defending Contractor in Construction Defect CaseAmbush Elections are Here—Are You Ready?A Property Tax Exemption, Misapplied, in TexasOnline Meetings & Privacy in Today’s WFH EnvironmentYellowstone Park Aims for Quick Reopening After FloodsKushner Company Files Suit Against Jersey City Over Delays to Planned TowersDesign Professionals Owe a Duty of Care to HomeownersConstruction Defects Claims Can Be Limited by Contract Says Washington CourtIRMI Expert Commentary: Managing Insurance Coverage from Multiple InsurersTrade Contract Revisions to Address COVID-19Federal Court Rejects Insurer's Argument that Wisconsin Has Adopted the Manifestation Trigger for Property PolicyDid You Really Accept That Bid? – How Contractors Can Avoid Post-Acceptance Bid Disputes Over Contract TermsAI-Powered Construction Optioneering TodayConstructive Notice Established as Obstacle to Relation Back DoctrineConsensusDOCS Updates its FormsReport: Construction Firms Could Better Protect Workers From Noise HazardsSave a Legal Fee: Prevent Costly Lawsuits With Claim Limitation ClausesTop
Hunton Insurance Coverage Group Ranked in National Tier 1 by US News & World Report
Homeowners Sue Over Sinkholes, Use Cash for Other Things
Disgruntled Online Reviews of Attorney by Disgruntled Former Client Ordered Removed from Yelp.com
Building with Recycled Plastics – Interview with Jeff Mintz of Envirolastech
Intel's $20B Ohio 'Mega-Site' is Latest Development in Chip Makers' Rush to Boost US Production
MTA Implements Revised Contractors Debarment Regulations
ASCE Releases First-of-its-Kind Sustainable Infrastructure Standard
Wilke Fleury Attorneys Highlighted | 2019 Northern California Super Lawyers
Guardrail Maker Defrauded U.S. of $175 Million and Created Hazard, Jury Says
Wood Product Rotting in New Energy Efficient Homes
What Types of “Damages Claims” Survive a Trustee’s Sale?
Homeowner's Claim for Collapse Survives Summary Judgment
Renters Trading Size for Frills Fuel U.S. Apartment Boom
Eighth Circuit Considers Judicial Estoppel in Hazardous Substance Release-Related Personal Injury Case
Construction Defect Not an Occurrence in Ohio
Urban Retrofits, Tall Buildings, and Sustainability
You May Be Able to Dodge a Bullet, But Not a Gatling Gun
"Damage to Your Product" Exclusion Bars Coverage
Soldiers Turn Brickies as U.K. Homebuilders Seek Workers
Eliminating Waste in Construction – An Interview with Turner Burton
Ten Firm Members Recognized as Super Lawyers or Rising Stars
Construction Litigation Roundup: “Stop - In the Name of the Law!”
Connecticut’s New False Claims Act Increases Risk to Public Construction Participants
With Vice President's Tie-Breaker, US Senate Approves Far-Reaching Climate Bill
Colorado Requires Builders to Accommodate High-Efficiency Devices in New Homes
Cross-Office Team Secures Defense Verdict in Favor of Client in Asbestos Case
First Look at Long List of AEC Firms Receiving PPP Loans
ABC, Via Construction Industry Safety Coalition, Comments on Silica Rule
Home Construction Slows in Las Vegas
Lease-Leaseback Fight Continues
An Expert’s Qualifications are Important
Did You Really Accept That Bid? – How Contractors Can Avoid Post-Acceptance Bid Disputes Over Contract Terms
New Executive Orders Expedite the Need for Contractors to Go Green
Is Construction Defect Litigation a Cause for Lack of Condos in Minneapolis?
Golf Resorts Offering Yoga, Hovercraft Rides to the Green
What Makes Building Ventilation Good Enough to Withstand a Pandemic?
LA’s $1.2 Billion Graffiti Towers Put on Sale After Bankruptcy
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (6/4/24) – New CRE Litmus Tests, Tech Integration in Real Estate and a Jump in Investor Home Purchases
Sureties do not Issue Bonds Risk-Free to the Bond-Principal
It’s Too Late, Lloyd’s: New York Federal Court Finds Insurer Waived Late Notice Defense
Creative Avenue for Judgment Creditor to Collect a Judgment
Homebuilder Confidence Takes a Beating
Maine Court Allows $1B Hydropower Transmission Project to Proceed
Construction in the Time of Coronavirus
'Taylor Swift Is an Economic Phenomenon': CE's Q1 2024 Economic Update and Forecast
Construction Defect Leads to Death of Worker
Does the Miller Act Trump Subcontract Dispute Provisions?
The Activist Group Suing the Suburbs for Bigger Buildings
Anatomy of a Construction Dispute- An Alternative
Important Environmental Insurance Ruling Issued In Protracted Insurance-Coverage Dispute
ferring to the Exculpated Party's NegligenceTraub Lieberman Partner Gregory S. Pennington and Associate Emily A. Velcamp Obtain Summary Judgment in Favor of Residential Property OwnersCourt Finds No Coverage for Workplace “Prank” With Nail GunWhile You Were Getting Worked Up Over Oil Prices, This Just Happened to SolarContractual “Pay if Paid” and “Pay when Paid” Clauses? What is a California Construction Subcontractor to Do? Scaffolding Collapse Kills Workers at China Construction SiteForeclosure Deficiency: Construction Loan vs. Home Improvement Loan 
