The Privette Doctrine and Its Exceptions: Court of Appeal Grapples With the Easy and Not So Easy
November 18, 2024 —
Garret Murai - California Construction Law BlogIn
CBRE v. Superior Court, 102 Cal.App.5th 639 (2024), the 4th District Court of Appeal grappled with a thorny and not-so-thorny issue involving injured parties under the Privette doctrine. The less thorny issue was whether application of the Privette doctrine depends on whether a written contract exists between the parties. Spoiler: It does not. The thorny issue was whether the Hooker exception to the Privette doctrine – which applies when a landowner exercises control over a project – should apply where a landowner directs a contractor to perform work that is at odds with legal requirements.
The CBRE Case
Property Reserve, Inc. owns an office building managed by CBRE in San Diego, California. On April 9, 2019, PRI entered into a lease agreement with a new tenant for a suite in the building. The lease required that PRI perform certain tenant improvements.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Garret Murai, Nomos LLPMr. Murai may be contacted at
gmurai@nomosllp.com
Summary Judgment for Insurer on Construction Defect Claim Reversed
January 07, 2025 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe Fifth Circuit reversed the district court's granting of summary judgment to the insurer on a construction defect claim asserted against the insured. TIG Ins. Co. v. Woodsboro Farmers Cooperative, 2024 U.S. App. LEXIS 24003 (5th Cir. Sept. 20, 2024).
In March 2013, Woodsboro Farmers Cooperative contracted with E.F. Erwin, Inc. to construct two Brock 105' diameter grain silos. Erwin hired subcontract AJ Constructors, Inc. (AJC) to construct the silos. Erwin was responsible for supervising the work.
Brock silos were kits shipped by the manufacturer and then assembled according to the manufacturer's manuals and specifications. The silos are constructed section by section. AJC began erecting the silos in May 2013 and completed its work in June or early July. Erwin occasionally inspected the work and found the silos were structurally sound and not defective. AJC left the job site after completing the assembly.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
Can Businesses Resolve Construction Disputes Outside of Court?
August 19, 2024 —
Scott L. Baker - Los Angeles Litigation BlogTime is of the essence in any construction project. So, if a dispute arises at any point, business owners generally wish to avoid the chance of a time-consuming case going to court.
Can California construction businesses
manage these disputes effectively outside of court? It is possible in some cases. Business owners should carefully consider these three steps.
1. Go Back to the Contract
Even if the contract is at the center of the dispute, it is important to refer to any details regarding dispute resolution included within the document. It is common for contracts to have some form of a dispute resolution clause. In such a case, both parties should follow the steps outlined in that agreement.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Scott L. Baker, Baker & AssociatesMr. Baker may be contacted at
slb@bakerslaw.com
Meet BWB&O’s 2025 Best Lawyers in America!
September 09, 2024 —
Dolores Montoya - Bremer Whyte Brown & O'Meara LLPBremer Whyte Brown & O’Meara, LLP is proud to announce Partners
Nicole Whyte,
Keith Bremer,
Vik Nagpal,
John O’Meara,
Sheila Stiles,
Patrick Au, and
Nicole Schmidt have been selected by their peers for inclusion in the 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America, and Partner
Devin Gifford, and Associates
Melissa Youngpeter,
Ryan Flanagan, and
Alexandria Zeis are included in the fifth edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America. Each person is being recognized for their diligent work in the areas of Family Law, Construction, Commercial, Personal Injury, and Real Estate Litigation.
Reprinted courtesy of
Dolores Montoya, Bremer Whyte Brown & O'Meara LLP
Read the full story...
GSA Releases Updated Standards to Accelerate Federal Buildings Toward Zero Emissions
August 12, 2024 —
The U.S. General Services AdministrationWASHINGTON — The U.S. General Services Administration (GSA) is advancing progress toward the Biden-Harris Administration's federal sustainability goals by releasing updated standards for federal buildings. P100 Facilities Standards for the Public Buildings Service establish mandatory design and construction standards and performance criteria for 300,000 federal buildings nationwide. The updated standards will help advance the adoption of cleaner, more efficient technologies for buildings; lead the way towards realizing the goals of the Federal Sustainability Plan to achieve net-zero emissions from all federal buildings by 2045; and promote the use of American-made, low carbon construction materials.
P100 requires that facilities adopt advanced energy conservation strategies and eliminate on-site fossil fuel use, directives that align with federal sustainability goals and will accelerate the transition to a clean energy economy. The industry-leading standard calls for grid-interactive efficient buildings, leverages innovative technologies through GSA's Green Proving Ground, requires the use of low-embodied carbon materials, and directs potable water reuse. These comprehensive measures ensure that new and renovated federal facilities achieve peak performance while minimizing environmental impact.
The 2024 P100 establishes exceptional benchmarks for:
- Electrification: New standards for building equipment and systems to be powered by clean energy sources.
- Embodied Carbon: Requirement to utilize low-embodied carbon materials, including salvaged, reused, regenerative, and biomimetic options.
- Energy Efficiency: Enhanced building envelope performance to minimize energy loss and improve overall efficiency.
- Grid-Interactive Efficient Buildings: New measures to support a more resilient, responsive grid.
- Water Reuse: Mandating that buildings have a 15% potable water reuse rate.
- Construction Decarbonization: Ground breaking new low-carbon methods for constructing federal buildings including clean energy operations, material salvage, and offsite assemblage.
- Labor Practices: New standards protecting workers from unfair or unsafe labor practices, ensuring supply chains are free from child and forced labor and that workers are protected from the impacts of extreme heat.
P100 is updated and published every three years. For more detailed information on the 2024 P100 and other GSA initiatives, visit www.gsa.gov/p100.
Definitions Matter in Illinois: Tenant Held Liable Only for Damage to Apartment Unit
September 09, 2024 —
Gus Sara - The Subrogation StrategistIn Phila. Indem. Ins. Co. v. Gonzalez, No. 1-23-0833, 2024 Ill. App. Unpub. LEXIS 1372, the Appellate Court of Illinois considered whether the terms of a lease agreement limited a tenant’s liability for fire damages, a fire caused by her negligence, to her apartment unit only. The plaintiff insured the subject apartment building, which incurred damage to several units as result of a fire in the tenant’s unit. The lease defined “Premises” as the specific apartment unit occupied by the tenant and held the tenant responsible for damage caused to the Premises. While the court found that the lease permitted the plaintiff to subrogate against the tenant, it held that the lease terms limited the damages to the tenant’s apartment unit only.
In Gonzalez, the plaintiff’s insured owned a multi-unit apartment building in Chicago. In September 2019, the building owner entered into a lease agreement with the defendant for apartment Unit 601. The lease stated that Unit 601 was the “Leased Address (Premises).” Another provision stated that building owner “hereby leases to Tenant(s) and Tenant(s) hereby leases from Landlord(s) for use as a private dwelling only, the Premises, together with the fixtures and appliances (if any) in the premises…” The lease also stated that “Tenant shall be liable for any damage done to the premises as a result of Tenant’s or Tenant’s invitees, guests or others authorized to reside in the Premises [sic] direct action, negligence, or failure to inform Landlord of repairs necessary to prevent damage to the Premises.”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Client Alert: Naming of Known and U
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (6/26/24) – Construction Growth in Office and Data Center Sectors, Slight Ease in Consumer Price Index and Increased Premiums for Commercial Buildings
Court of Appeals Affirms Dismissal of Owner’s Claims Based on Contractual One-Year Claims Limitations Period
Resulting Loss Provision Does Not Salvage Coverage
In Hong Kong, You Can Find a Home Where the Buffalo Roam
Edison Utility Accused of Igniting LA Fire in Lawsuits
One More Statutory Tweak of Interest to VA Construction Pros
California Makes Big Changes to the Discovery Act
Stadium Intended for the 2010 World Cup Still Not Ready
No Bond, No Recovery: WA Contractors Must Comply With WA Statutory Requirements Or Risk Being Barred From Recovery If Their Client Refuses To Pay
Kahana Feld Partner Jeff Miragliotta and Senior Associate Rachael Marvin Obtain Early Dismissal of Commercial Litigation Cases in New York and New Jersey
Tetra Tech-U.S. Cleanup Dispute in San Francisco Grows
Dorian Lashes East Canada, Then Weakens Heading Out to Sea
Colorado Senate Bill 13-052: The “Transit-Oriented Development Claims Act of 2013.”
Goldman Veteran Said to Buy Mortgages After Big Short
Pollution Exclusion Found Ambiguous
The Law Clinic Paves Way to the Digitalization of Built Environment Processes
Washington State May Allow Common Negligence Claims against Construction Professionals
San Diego’s NFL Stadium Dream Counts on Munis for Chargers’ Home
COVID-19 Response: Essential Business Operations: a High-Stakes Question Under Proliferating “Stay at Home” Orders
Note on First-Party and Third-Party Spoliation of Evidence Claims
Damages or Injury “Likely to Occur” or “Imminent” May No Longer Trigger Insurance Coverage
2018 Super Lawyers and Rising Stars!
New York Appellate Division: Second Department Contradicts First Department, Denying Insurer's Recoupment of Defense Costs for Uncovered Claims
California Department of Corrections Gets Hit With the Prison Bid Protest Blues
Construction Contracts Need Amending Post COVID-19 Shutdowns
Proposition 65: OEHHA to Consider Adding and Delisting Certain Chemicals of Concern
New Homes in Palo Alto to Be Electric-Car Ready
Spearin Doctrine: Alive, Well and Thriving on its 100th Birthday
Celebrating Excellence: Lisa Bondy Dunn named by Law Week Colorado as the 2024 Barrister’s Best Construction Defects Lawyer for Defendants
Safety Officials Investigating Death From Fall
Motion to Dismiss Denied Regarding Insureds' Claim For Collapse
Appraisal May Include Cause of Loss Issues
House Approves $715B Transportation and Water Infrastructure Bill
Jury Could Have Found That Scissor Lift Manufacturer Should Have Included “Better” Safety Features
Appellate Attorney’s Fees and the Significant Issues Test
The Quiet War Between California’s Charter Cities and the State’s Prevailing Wage Law
Architect Not Responsible for Injuries to Guests
Demanding a Reduction in Retainage
Appraisal Panel Can Determine Causation of Loss under Ohio Law
Missouri Asbestos Litigation Reform: New Bill Seeks to Establish Robust Disclosure Obligations
Maritime Law: An Albatross for Contractors Navigating Marine Construction
Can a Non-Signatory Invoke an Arbitration Provision?
The Preservation Maze
Less Than Perfectly Drafted Endorsement Bars Flood Coverage
Manufacturer of Asbestos-Free Product May Still Be Liable for Asbestos Related Injuries
Three Steps to a Safer Jobsite
"Ordinance or Law" Provision Mandates Coverage for Roof Repair
No Coverage for Restoring Aesthetic Uniformity
CSLB Reminds California Public Works Contractors to Renew Their Public Works Registration
Contractors Prepare for a Strong 2021 Despite Unpredictability
>U.K. High Court COVID-19 Victory for Policyholders May Set a Trend in the U.S.John Paulson’s $1 Billion Caribbean Empire Faces BetrayalPolicy Language Matters: New Jersey Court Bars Cleanup Coverage Under Broad Policy TermsIn UK, 16th Century Abbey Modernizes Heating System by Going Back to Roman TimesThree Attorneys Named Among The Best Lawyers in America 2018560">
The Unpost, Post: Dynamex and the Construction IndianapolisDespite Misapplying California Law, Federal Court Acknowledges Virus May Cause Physical Alteration to Property The Court-Side Seat: FERC Reviews, Panda Power Plaints and Sovereign ImmunityThe Biggest Thing Keeping Young Homebuyers out of the Market Isn't Student DebtFlorida Enacts Property Insurance Overhaul for Benefit of PolicyholdersClient Alert: Expert Testimony in Indemnity Action Not Limited to Opinions Presented in Underlying MatterDC Metro Extension’s Precast Supplier Banned from Federal ContractsIncorporation by Reference in Your Design Services Contract– What Does this Mean, and Are You at Risk? (Law Note)Short on Labor, Israeli Builders Seek to Vaccinate PalestiniansThe Private Works: Preliminary Notice | Are You Using the Correct Form?Colorado House Bill 17-1279 – A Misguided Attempt at Construction Defect Reform More Details Emerge in Fatal Charlotte, NC, Scaffold CollapseMore Regulations for Federal ContractorsWhat a Difference a Day Makes: Mississippi’s Discovery RuleThe Risk of A Fixed Price Contract Is The Market 
