COVID-19 Business Interruption Claims Four Years Later: What Have We Learned?
September 23, 2024 —
Patrick McKnight - The Dispute ResolverFour and half years ago the COVID-19 pandemic spread around the globe, bringing with it interesting, but challenging, legal problems for construction attorneys. Construction projects ground to a halt. Ever-changing guidance from authorities ranging from the U.S. Department of Labor to local health authorities resulted in a web of evolving obligations for general contractors and subs alike. One of the most closely watched legal questions was the wave of business interruption claims filed by plaintiffs, many of whom owned businesses impacted by government shutdowns. During the opening months of the pandemic, I
noted that hundreds of business interruption claims had been filed by insureds across the country. At that time, the only thing certain was that although the outcome remained unknown, virus exclusions were likely to become more likely in the future. Needless to say, much has happened since early 2020.
What does the data say about the outcome of business interruption claims?
In sum, plaintiffs have had an uphill battle. A helpful resource for analyzing the outcome of business interruption suits is the
Covid Coverage Litigation Tracker (“Tracker”), an insurance law analytics tool offered by Penn Carey Law of the University of Pennsylvania. According to its website, “[t]he Covid Coverage Litigation Tracker is a multi-sourced database and dashboard through which to view the unfolding insurance litigation arising out of the pandemic in federal and state courts. Widely cited in briefs, judicial opinions, and the press, the tracker also serves as a proof of concept for new methods to identify, track, and understand emerging case congregations in real time.”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Patrick McKnight, Fox Rothschild LLPMr. McKnight may be contacted at
pmcknight@foxrothschild.com
The 2023 Term of the Supreme Court: Administrative and Regulatory Law Rulings
December 03, 2024 —
Anthony B. Cavender - Gravel2Gavel Construction & Real Estate Law BlogIt is instructive to review the Supreme Court’s record in its most recent term, concentrating on regulatory and administrative law cases, which are usually back-burner issues. But not this term.
The Supreme Court began the current term on October 7, 2024. The Court has already chosen many cases to review in the new term, and it promises to be as interesting as the 2023 term, which produced several significant rulings affecting regulatory and administrative law, chiefly the Loper Bright Enterprises ruling. Loper Bright overturned the Court’s landmark administrative law ruling of Chevron, USA v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc., 467 U.S. 837 (1984).
The Background to Loper Bright
In 1984, the Supreme Court decided Chevron USA, Inc. v. National Resource Defense Council. (See 467 U.S. 839 (1984).) The unanimous decision, written by Justice Stevens, reversed then-D.C. Circuit Judge Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s ruling that set aside EPA’s Clean Air Act “bubble policy,” which was intended to provide regulatory relief from certain EPA permitting requirements.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Anthony B. Cavender, PillsburyMr. Cavender may be contacted at
anthony.cavender@pillsburylaw.com
Wildfire Risk Harms California Home Values, San Francisco Fed Study Finds
August 26, 2024 —
Laura Curtis - BloombergCalifornia’s wildfires are weighing on home prices more than in the past, and insurance availability does little to help in areas considered to be at higher risk, according to a Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco study.
“Our results suggest that property values have been more adversely impacted in recent years by being close to past wildfires than was the case previously,” economists Leila Bengali, Fernanda Nechio and Stephanie Stewart wrote in a paper published Monday on the Fed bank’s website.
While the effect of the proximity may be relatively small now, the economists warned “this pattern may become stronger in years to come if residential construction continues to expand into areas with higher fire risk and if trends in wildfire severity continue,” the study cautioned.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Laura Curtis, Bloomberg
Unlocking the Hidden Power of Zoning, for Good or Bad
October 21, 2024 —
David Zipper - BloombergNo longer dismissed as an insomnia-curing corner of local governance, zoning is having a moment. It’s at the heart of the pro-housing Yes In My Backyard — or YIMBY — movement, which seeks to reform the rules that mandate the construction of single-family homes across much of the US, and the arcane details of land use policy are being debated in national outlets and city councils across the US. In much of this discourse, zoning is the clear villain, blamed for feeding societal ills ranging from housing costs to racial discrimination to greenhouse gas emissions.
In her new book Key to the City, Sara Bronin examines zoning with a critical but sympathetic eye. Bronin brings deep experience to the topic, having studied zoning as an architect and lawyer before overhauling the land use regulations of Hartford, Connecticut. A professor of architecture and planning at Cornell University (and an occasional Bloomberg CityLab contributor), she is currently on leave to chair the federal Advisory Council on Historic Preservation.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Zipper, Bloomberg
Contractual Fee-Shifting in Litigation: Who Pays the Price?
December 31, 2024 —
Caitlin Kicklighter - ConsensusDocsWhen disputes on a construction project escalate to litigation, general contractors may find themselves entangled in a costly and time-consuming legal battle. One important concept to understand is contractual fee-shifting under a “prevailing party” provision, which can significantly impact damages recovered in litigation. The general rule, known as the “American Rule,” requires each party to pay its own legal costs, including attorney’s fees, expert witness expenses, and other court-related costs. This differs from other legal systems where the losing party typically pays the winning party’s fees. One exception to the American Rule is contractual fee-shifting, specifically through “prevailing party” provisions, which allows for the award of attorney’s fees and costs when explicitly provided for in a contract.
This article explores this exception to the American Rule, delves into the challenges posed by prevailing party provisions, and shares tips to consider for drafting these clauses to improve clarity and minimize uncertainty in the face of litigation.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Caitlin Kicklighter, Jones Walker LLPMs. Kicklighter may be contacted at
ckicklighter@joneswalker.com
Meet BWB&O’s 2025 Best Lawyers in America!
September 09, 2024 —
Dolores Montoya - Bremer Whyte Brown & O'Meara LLPBremer Whyte Brown & O’Meara, LLP is proud to announce Partners
Nicole Whyte,
Keith Bremer,
Vik Nagpal,
John O’Meara,
Sheila Stiles,
Patrick Au, and
Nicole Schmidt have been selected by their peers for inclusion in the 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America, and Partner
Devin Gifford, and Associates
Melissa Youngpeter,
Ryan Flanagan, and
Alexandria Zeis are included in the fifth edition of Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch in America. Each person is being recognized for their diligent work in the areas of Family Law, Construction, Commercial, Personal Injury, and Real Estate Litigation.
Reprinted courtesy of
Dolores Montoya, Bremer Whyte Brown & O'Meara LLP
Read the full story...
America’s Bridges and the Need for Bridge Infrastructure Investment
January 07, 2025 —
Lisa D. Love - The Dispute ResolverDuring the October 2024 meeting of the American Bar Association’s Forum on Construction held in Pittsburgh, a city of many bridges, the importance of bridges to our nation’s transportation infrastructure was apparent. Just two years ago, the Forbes Avenue bridge in Pittsburgh collapsed—resulting in several vehicles and a bus falling into a ravine. Ten people were injured in the event. It was later reported that the bridge had received a “poor” rating but was still permitted to remain open to traffic. The event resulted in several lawsuits which, just this past September, the City of Pittsburgh requested $500,000 from the city council to settle. The Forbes Avenue bridge is hardly a unique case and is just one example of the litigation that can ensue if we fail to maintain our aging infrastructure.
Suffolk Pauses $1.5B Boston Tower Project for Safety Audit After FireFederal Court Finds Occurrence for Faulty Workmanship Under Virginia LawFailing to Pay Prevailing Wages May Have Just Cost You More Than You ThoughtSenator Ray Scott Introduced a Bill to Reduce Colorado’s Statute of Repose for Construction Defect Actions to Four YearsMore on Fraud, Opinions and ContractsThird Circuit Follows Pennsylvania Law - Damage Caused by Faulty Workmanship Does Not Arise from an OccurrenceInsurer Must Cover Portions of Arbitration AwardTrial Court’s Grant of Summary Judgment On Ground Not Asserted By Moving Party UpheldBuilders Beware: A New Class Of Defendants In Asbestos LawsuitsWhat California’s COVID-19 Reopening Means for the Construction Industry Toll Plans to Boost New York Sales With Pricing, IncentivesNew York City Dept. of Buildings Explores Drones for Facade InspectionsInsureds Survive Summary Judgment on Coverage for Hurricane LossIllinois Appellate Court Addresses Professional Services Exclusion in Homeowners PolicyFederal Regulatory Recap: A Summary of Recent Rulemaking Actions Taken or Proposed Affecting the Energy IndustryBig League Dreams a Nightmare for TownCourt Says KBR Construction Costs in Iraq were UnreasonableWave Breaker: How a Living Shoreline Will Protect a Florida Highway and Oyster BedThe “Program Accessibility” Exception for Public Entities Under the ADAVenue for Suing Public Payment BondApartment Investors Turn to Suburbs After Crowding CitiesKY Mining Accident Not a Covered Occurrence Under Commercial General Liability PolicyWichita Condo Association Files Construction Defect LawsuitThe General Assembly Seems Ready to Provide Some Consistency in Mechanic’s Lien WaiverOregon Court of Appeals Rules That Negligent Construction (Construction Defect) Claims Are Subject to a Two-Year Statute of LimitationsHouse of the Week: Spanish Dream Home on California's RivieraContractor Haunted by “Demonized” FlooringThere’s the 5 Second Rule, But Have You Heard of the 5 Year Rule?What You Need to Know About Home Improvement Contracts Landmark Montana Supreme Court Decision Series: Known Loss Doctrine & Interpretation of “Occurrence”Cybersecurity on Your Project: Why Not Follow National Security Strategy?Massachusetts Court Holds Statute of Repose Bars Certain Asbestos-Related Construction ClaimsNew Insurance Case: Owners' Insurance Barred in Reimbursement Action against Tenant City Council Authorizes Settlement of Basement Flooding CasesBlackstone Suffers Court Setback in Irish Real Estate DramaConsiderations in Obtaining a Mechanic’s Lien in Maryland (Don’t try this at home)Pennsylvania Considers Changes to Construction Code ReviewDrop in Civil Trials May Cause Problems for Construction Defect CasesImpasse Over Corruption Charges Costs SNC $3.7 Billion, CEO SaysHybrid Contracts for The Sale of Goods and Services and the Predominant Factor TestEight Ways to Protect a Construction Company Before a Claim Is FiledCourt of Appeals Discusses Implied Duty of Good Faith and Fair Dealing in Public Works ContractingNewmeyer Dillion Named 2021 Best Law Firm in Multiple Practice Areas by U.S. News-Best LawyersMichigan Supreme Court Finds Faulty Subcontractor Work That Damages Insured’s Work Product May Constitute an “Occurrence” Under CGL PolicyCDJ’s #7 Topic of the Year: The Las Vegas Harmon Hotel Year-Long Demolition & Trial BeginsThe Future of High-Rise is Localized and ResponsiveCourt Clarifies Sequence in California’s SB800California Supreme Court Protects California Policyholders for Intentional Acts of EmployeesYellowstone Park Aims for Quick Reopening After FloodsHistorical Long-Tail Claims in California Subject to a Vertical Exhaustion RuleCongratulations to San Diego Partner Johnpaul Salem and Senior Associate Scott Hoy for Obtaining a Complete Defense Verdict!Got Licensing Questions? CSLB Licensing Workshop November 17th and December 15thPayne & Fears LLP Recognized by U.S. News & World Report and Best Lawyers in 2023 “Best Law Firms” RankingsCalifornia Statutes Authorizing Public-Private Partnership ContractingSDNY Vacates Arbitration Award for Party-Arbitrator’s NondisclosuresTraub Lieberman Partner Adam Joffe Named to 2022 Emerging Lawyers ListHomebuilders Go Green in Response to Homebuyer Demand Why 8 Out of 9 Californians Don't Buy Earthquake InsuranceOrion Group Holdings Honored with Leadership in Safety AwardCaterpillar Forecast Tops Estimates as Construction RecoversA Bill for an Act Concerning Workers’ Compensation – 2014 EditionMark Van Wonterghem To Serve as Senior Forensic Consultant in the Sacramento Offices of Bert L. Howe & Associates, Inc.Colorado homebuilders target low-income buyers with bogus "affordable housing" billViva La France! 2024 Summer Olympics Construction Features Sustainable Design, Including, Simply Not Building at All/>
