Surprising Dismissal of False Claims Act Case Based on Appointments Clause - What Does It Mean?
October 15, 2024 —
Steven H. Lee - Lewis Brisbois NewsroomAtlanta, Ga. (October 1, 2024) - In a surprising turn of events, the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida recently dismissed a False Claims Act (FCA) lawsuit brought by relator Clarissa Zafirov against Florida Medical Associates, LLC, and other defendants. U.S. District Judge Kathryn Kimball Mizelle
ruled that the FCA’s qui tam provisions, which allow private individuals to bring lawsuits on behalf of the government, violate the Constitution’s Appointments Clause.
This decision follows another unexpected ruling by U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon in the Southern District of Florida, where the court similarly dismissed an indictment against former President Donald Trump based on the same constitutional clause.
At the heart of these rulings is the argument that FCA relators - who decide whom to sue, which legal theories to pursue, and how to proceed - exercise significant executive authority. Because they are not appointed by the President, a department head, or a court, the judges concluded that these relators hold their positions unconstitutionally. As a result, Judge Mizelle dismissed the case entirely.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Steven H. Lee, Lewis BrisboisMr. Lee may be contacted at
Steven.Lee@lewisbrisbois.com
Best Lawyers Honors Hundreds of Lewis Brisbois Attorneys, Names Four Partners ‘Lawyers of the Year’
September 16, 2024 —
Lewis Brisbois Newsroom(August 15, 2024) - Best Lawyers has selected 171 Lewis Brisbois attorneys across 47 offices for its 31st edition of The Best Lawyers in America. It has also recognized four Lewis Brisbois partners on its "Lawyers of the Year" list: San Diego Partner Gary K. Brucker Jr. (Litigation - Real Estate); Weirton Managing Partner Michelle L. Gorman (Mass Tort Litigation/Class Actions - Defendants); Roanoke Partner Paul C. Kuhnel (Medical Malpractice Law - Defendants); and Los Angeles Co-Administrative Partner Steven R. Lewis (Product Liability Litigation - Defendants).
Please join us in congratulating the following attorneys on their Best Lawyers recognition! You can see the full list of attorneys named to Best Lawyers' Ones to Watch in America
here.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Lewis Brisbois
What Every Project Participant Needs to Know About Delay Claims
August 05, 2024 —
Andrew G. Vicknair - The Dispute ResolverA “delay” on a construction project is defined as the stretching out of the time for completion of certain key milestone scopes of work which can impact the completion date of an entire project, due to some circumstances or events that were not reasonably anticipated when the project began. 2 Construction Law ¶ 6.01 (Matthew Bender, 2024). While delays can be caused by any number of events, the most common are defective plans and specifications; design changes; severe weather and other, similar unforeseeable events; unforeseen or differing site conditions; unavailability of materials or labor; labor inefficiencies or stoppages; contractor negligence; and owner influences, including construction changes or outright interference by the owner or its agents. If the project schedule is not recovered following a delay, then the project schedule will likely be extended, resulting in an increase in the contractor’s costs of performance. A contractor that has experienced a delay on a project can take certain actions to pursue recovery of any damages the contractor may have incurred. However, to do so it is important to understand the different types of delays and the methods for establishing the delays.
I. Types of Delays
Delays may be categorized as (1) critical versus non-critical delays, (2) excusable versus non-excusable delays, and (3) compensable versus non-compensable delays. A critical delay is a delay that affects the project completion date and delays the entire project. In essence, a critical delay is one that will extend the critical path of a project. A non-critical delay is a delay that has no effect on the project’s critical path. Courts have recognized that delays to work not on the critical path will generally not delay the completion of a project. G.M. Shupe, Inc. v U.S., 5 Cl. Ct. 662, 728 (1984). Such a non-critical delay may affect the completion of certain activities, but does not affect the completion date of the entire project. In order for a delay to provide the basis for a claim for additional time or money, the delay must impact critical path activities on the project schedule.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Andrew G. Vicknair, D'Arcy Vicknair, LLCMr. Vicknair may be contacted at
agv@darcyvicknair.com
Climate Disasters Are an Affordable Housing Problem
October 01, 2024 —
Juan Pablo Garnham & Arjuna Heim - BloombergWhen Maui was devastated by wildfires in August 2023, some residents were initially fortunate. The neighborhood of Makawao, for example, was spared the worst effects of the fire that engulfed Lahaina, 35 miles to the west.
Recently, though, we met a woman in that neighborhood who faces a different kind of threat: Her landlord has now demanded that she pay double her rent or face eviction. As housing advocates in the region, we’ve heard stories like this repeatedly, as residents report an acute fear of displacement and homelessness.
A year after the fires killed more than 100 people, displaced 12,000 and disrupted the economy of the island, the disaster lingers for many in Maui and Hawai'i. Rents across the island have increased sharply, offering a cautionary tale for the rest of the US about how climate change, a housing crisis and the lack of adequate public policies can multiply the suffering of a community already in pain.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Bloomberg
Snooze You Lose? Enforcement of Notice and Timing Provisions
November 11, 2024 —
Cornelius F. "Lee" Banta, Jr. - ConsensusDocsDeadlines are an inescapable part of the construction industry. Bid deadlines. Submittal deadlines. Material delivery deadlines. Substantial completion. Final completion. And so, inevitably, fighting about deadlines becomes a necessary byproduct. Was the deadline really a deadline? Was the schedule slippage on the critical path? Should there be an equitable extension to the date of substantial completion? Given the amount of attention and concern conferred on deadlines, those drafting construction contracts naturally seek to clarify which deadlines really matter with the inclusion of notice and timing provisions.
A contract’s change order and claims procedures are often a key friction point for those drafting and administering the contract. Should there be a requirement for prior written notice of a claim for cost/time relief? How much advance notice? Who should the request be sent to? Is a specific form of notice required? What are the consequences of failing to provide timely notice? A practitioner should pay careful attention to negotiating these terms on the front end, because rest assured, these contract provisions will garner scrutiny when a change order dispute boils over.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Cornelius F. "Lee" Banta, Jr., Peckar & Abramson, P.C.Mr. Banta may be contacted at
lbanta@pecklaw.com
California Supreme Court Finds Vertical Exhaustion Applies to First-Level Excess Policies
August 26, 2024 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiAddressing issues left open in its seminal decision in Montrose, the California Supreme Court found that the language in the first-level excess policies meant that the insured could access the policies upon exhaustion of the directly underlying policies purchased for the same policy period. Truck Ins. Exchange v. Kaiser Cement & Gypsum Corp., 2024 Cal. LEXIS 3271 (Cal. June 17, 2024).
From 1944 through the 1970's, Kaiser manufactured asbestos-containing products at numerous different facilities. By 2004, more than 24,000 claimants had filed product liability claims against Kaiser alleging that they had suffered bodily injury as a result of exposure to Kaiser's asbestos products. Kaiser tendered these claims to Truck, one of several primary insurers that had issued CGL policies to Kaiser.
In 2001, Truck initiated this coverage action to determine its indemnity and defense obligations to Kaiser. Truck later amended its complaint to add a cause of action for contribution against several of Kaiser's excess insurers. The issue presently before the court was whether Truck was entitled to contribution from various coinsurers that issued first-level excess policies to Kaiser during the period in question.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
Toolbox Talk Series Recap - The New Science of Jury Trial Advocacy
December 31, 2024 —
Douglas J. Mackin - The Dispute ResolverIn the November 21, 2024 edition of Division 1's Toolbox Talk Series,
John Jerry Glas discussed how construction lawyers should adjust their trial strategies in response to shifts in juror attitudes. Glas believes that jurors have changed in the last twenty years, with modern jurors being more reluctant than ever to be seen as a lawyer’s puppet. Instead, they simply want a lawyer to help them organize and wade through evidence without spinning it and without spoon-feeding it. Essentially, Glas believes that lawyers achieve better jury trial results if they acknowledge the paradigm shift in jury psychology and reinvent themselves in response by influencing jury deliberations without directly telling a jury what to do. Glas refers to this as the “Waiter Pivot” and recently published a
book on the topic.
Throughout his presentation, Glas discussed how construction lawyers can embrace the Waiter Pivot throughout a jury trial:
- Voir Dire: Lawyers make their first impressions on a jury during voir dire. As such, lawyers should avoid questions that make jurors feel judged or stereotyped. Instead, give the jurors credit and make use of the opportunity to begin framing their case. For example, Glas once repeated the word “specifications” or “specs” in every question during voir dire where his product liability case turned on whether or not the product deviated from specifications.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Douglas J. Mackin, Cozen O’ConnorMr. Mackin may be contacted at
dmackin@cozen.comRepairs to Water Infrastructure Underway After Hurricane HeleneThree Attorneys Elevated to Partner at Newmeyer & Dillion, LLPMiller Act Claim for Unsigned Change OrdersForeign Entry into the United States Construction, Infrastructure and PPP MarketsIn Texas, a General Contractor May be Liable in Tort to a Third-Party Lessee for Property Damage Caused by a Subcontractor’s WorkPaycheck Protection Flexibility Act Of 2020: What You Need to KnowDid Deutsche Make a Deal with the Wrong Homeowner?Construction Warranties: Have You Seen Me Lately?KF-103 v. American Family Mutual Insurance: Tenth Circuit Upholds the “Complaint Rule”General Contractors: Consider Importance of "Primary Noncontributory" LanguageMBS’s $500 Billion Desert Dream Just Keeps Getting WeirderSixth Circuit Finds No Coverage for Faulty Workmanship Under Kentucky LawPCL Sues Big Bank for $30M in Claimed NJ Mall Unpaid WorkBert L. Howe & Associates Brings Professiona
Montrose Language Interpreted: How Many Policies Are Implicated By A Construction Defect That Later Causes a Flood?
Florida Contractor on Trial for Bribing School Official
Bad Faith Jury Verdict Upheld After Insurer's Failure to Settle Within Policy Limits
Can a Non-Signatory Invoke an Arbitration Provision?
Massive Fire Destroys Building, Firefighters Rescue Construction Worker
Benefits and Pitfalls of Partnerships Between Companies
Real Estate & Construction News Round-Up (11/02/22) – Flexible Workspaces, Sustainable Infrastructure, & Construction Tech
Architect Sues over Bidding Procedure
New Addition to the ASCE/SEI 7-22 Standard Protects Buildings from a 500-year Flood Event
Lien Actions Versus Lien Foreclosure Actions
AB 1701 Has Passed – Developers and General Contractors Are Now Required to Double Pay for Labor Due to Their Subcontractors’ Failure to Pay
Congratulations to Haight Attorneys Selected to the 2020 Southern California Super Lawyers List
Bridge Disaster - Italy’s Moment of Truth
BHA has a Nice Swing Donates to CDCCF
FIFA May Reduce World Cup Stadiums in Russia on Economic Concern
Burg Simpson to Create Construction Defect Group
Faulty Workmanship an Occurrence in Iowa – as Long as Other Property Damage is Involved
The Argument for Solar Power
Question of Parties' Intent Prevents Summary Judgment for Insurer
Pulte’s Kitchen Innovation Throw Down
Do Change Orders Need to be in Writing and Other Things That Might Surprise You
Make Prudent Decisions regarding your Hurricane Irma Property Damage Claims
Hawaii Supreme Court Finds Excess Can Sue Primary for Equitable Subrogation
Claim for Collapse After Demolition of Building Fails
Fourteen Years as a Solo!
Will the Hidden Cracks in the Bay Bridge Cause Problems During an Earthquake?
California Court of Appeal Holds That the Right to Repair Act Prohibits Class Actions Against Manufacturers of Products Completely Manufactured Offsite
Insurance Policy’s “No Voluntary Payment” Clauses Lose Some Bite in Colorado
Legislative Update on Bills of Note (Updated Post-Adjournment)
Blog Completes Sixteenth Year
Latest Updates On The Coronavirus Pandemic
Business Interruption, Food Spoilage Claims Resulting from Off Premise Power Failure Denied
Denial of Coverage for Bulge in Wall Upheld
Burden to Prove Exception to Exclusion Falls on Insured
Drop in Civil Trials May Cause Problems for Construction Defect Cases
What You Need to Know About CARB’s In-Use Off-Road Diesel Regulations
Plehat Brings Natural Environments into Design Tools
Expansion of Statutes of Limitations and Repose in K-12 and Municipal Construction Contracts
Texas and Georgia Are Paying the Price for Sprawl
Construction Defect Fund Approved for Bankrupt Las Vegas Builder
Stop by BHA’s Booth at WCC and Support the Susan G. Komen Foundation
Not So Fast, My Friend: Pacing and Concurrent Delay
Chinese Telecommunications Ban to Expand to Federally Funded Contracts Effective November 12, 2020
Defects in Texas High School Stadium Angers Residents
Competent, Substantial Evidence Carries Day in Bench Trial
Real Estate & Construction News Roundup (4/10/24) – Hotels Integrate AI, Baby-Boomers Stay Put, and Insurance Affects Housing Market
New Home Construction Booming in Texas
Insurance Policy Provides No Coverage For Slab Collapse in Vision One
Unit Owners Have No Standing to Sue under Condominium Association’s Policy
Beyond the Disneyland Resort: Dining
